Hi, everybody. I'm Josh Mankiewicz, and we are talking Dateline. And our guest today is Keith Morrison.

Hi. Hello, Josh. How are you?

This is starting off about the way I expected.

It's really quite delightful to talk to you, Josh.

That's much better. That suggests that you've made some progress since the last time we did this. So this episode is called the Nighttime stopped. And if you haven't seen it or if you haven't listened to it, it is the episode right below this one on the list of podcasts that you just chose from. So go there and listen to it or watch it on tv or stream it on Peacock and then come back here. Today, I've got some questions for Keith about this latest episode. Keith also has an extra clip that was not on the episode that he's going to play for us. And then later we are going to talk to you. We're going to take some of your viewer questions and listener questions about this episode from social media. So let's talk Dateline. Where to begin here? This was a very recent story as DatElIne episodes go. I mean, it happened in May of 2022, and I think you did the first episode on this later that year.

Yes. Yes, indeed. And we were running around the continent trying to catch up with everybody who knew what was going on, and we were able to get the outlines of the story all right. Before the trial actually began. And then this is a deep dive that we couldn't do before we have all the information. And we were able to talk to a great many more of the people who were involved in these strange events.

Because sometimes people are not available when it first happens because they are unprepared and because they don't want to get involved. And then as time passes, they read about it. Maybe they're mentioned in some of the articles or stories about the thing, and now they do want to talk.

And what happens, too, as you know, is that people who are going about the business of investigating and prosecuting these cases often don't feel that they're able to speak about it before the trial actually happens. They want to do their talking at trial. Understood. So last time around, the prosecutor wasn't talking to us. The detectives were unable to be very revealing. Of course, the US marshals couldn't talk to us at all in this case. Now everybody has come forward to tell the whole story, and that just makes it far richer and more interesting.

The interesting thing about this, I thought, is how hard it is to hide from law enforcement. Caitlin Armstrong, her on the run with the yoga mat under her arm is just one of the most remarkable things I've ever seen on DAteline.

Isn't that interesting? Yeah. And her trying to settle into a little beach community in this country, I guess thinking or hoping that somehow she had evaded responsibility for this crime and she could go on with her life, you know, as if nothing happened, was so telling. But, I mean, it's magical thinking and it's desperation and the rest of it. But the fact that she would go to the trouble of getting plastic surgery to try to make her face look different and she would color her hair, but her hair was so important to her that she wouldn't do the obvious thing and just cut it off. Cut it off? Yeah.

Getting plastic surgery to avoid detection is like, first of all, it's like something out of like the fifties and sixties, you know?

Well, it's like from watching a James Bond movie or something.

Yeah, right. And also, by the way, like, unless you've got like a couple of hundred thousand dollars, it's not going to change your look so much that you won't be recognized by law enforcement.

No, no. You can barely tell the difference at all, in fact. But what was fascinating to me was that the plastic surgeon who spoke to us, his story about her behavior was fascinating and that she did not want to have her photograph taken before or at any time during the process. And she wore a mask in, and she had most of her face covered the whole time. And clearly was somebody who was trying to hide from any photographs.

Do we know how much money she paid for that plastic surgery?

We had the bill. I forget offhand what it was. It was much less than it would cost in the United States, let me put it that way.

Okay. Well, I mean, look, she didn't come out looking bad, but she certainly didn't disguise herself in the way that she.

No, she did not. She did not. I found it fascinating. The detectives, we questioned them a little bit about why it took them so long for the marshals to get their butts down there to Costa Rica to do the looking. Then they explained to us how it works, that if you really want to find somebody in a country of several million people, if you just fly down there and start going, it's just not going to work out. You'll never find them. So you get the US consulate involved and you get people on the ground there already to kind of try to sector out the country for you and figure out where to look. It was difficult to do this because most of the photographs of her were her kind of grinning away. They wanted one of her not smiling.

I thought that was very clever of them. Yeah.

Yeah. And they spent some time, some extra time to get that photograph. And, you know, that was what did it. They were able to look into her eyes as they saw it in that unsmiling photograph, and they knew for sure they. They had their woman.

I just thought that was all very smart detective work.

It was good. And actually having one of their agents take the yoga classes to see whether or not she was an instructor. Then once again, her magical thinking had her trying to evade capture right up until the last moment she picked the.

Lock on her handcuffs.

Well, again, it's these decisions made in desperation. Right? What would make her think. What in heaven's name would make her think that she could, while she was in custody, sneak a pin into her hand and then use it to take off her handcuffs and somehow run fast enough to evade capture and what, leave the country again? Get to an airport somehow with no money at all, get on a plane and fly to, I don't know where this time.

No money, no. No id, and wearing, you know, wearing jail. Jail clothing.

I know. Bizarre.

I mean, she did a lot of what would be, you know, sort of objectively speaking, smart things to, you know, get off the grid, get away. And it didn't work. They found her.

Yeah. They would have been smart things 15 or 20 years ago. They're not anymore. You know, it's very, very difficult to commit that kind of a crime and get away with it nowadays because of the fact that you're tracked everywhere you go. If you've got a cell phone with you, you're tracked, whether it's on or off. If you're driving around in a car, that car records where you go and when you go there.

I did not realize that your car can give law enforcement as much information as it did. I know that in the Murdoch case in South Carolina, that was a similar thing. They got a lot of info from the car.

Yes. I was surprised by that. I had no idea.

A couple other things. I mean, they used Facebook to help find her, which was clever. And the thing about the app, about Caitlin, using the cycling app to straw. Yeah, that was.

That was creepy.

Yeah.

Well, that told you that she was planning this and that this wasn't a spur of the moment thing. But the Strava thing was weird. It was when you can go online, if you're a famous cyclist, as Mo was automatically, you put up all your rides on Strava. So that other cyclists can see where you're riding and can kind of follow your progress.

Probably never occurred to her. That was a way that could lead someone to her for a terrible reason.

No, no. Watching her all that day and then back to that little apartment, it's an awful thing.

I thought that ring camera video and the audio that came from it was really chilling.

Yeah, it was chilling. Yeah. You know, a lot of the victims about whom we do stories are people I wish I had known. And Mo Wilson ranks very high in that list because everything that I heard about her was about what a good person she was, what a kind person she was, what a humble person she was. And some of you would want to know. So you really begin to feel more connected to this whole business when you know more about the victim. And then to hear that sound, to hear those screams, to recognize that that was her being murdered, that hit pretty hard.

That was. That was. I agree. That was really chilling.

Yeah. Yeah.

Well, let's. Let's take a break. When we come back, we have an extra clip from one of Collins interviews with police that did not make it into the broadcast.

Hey, guys, Willie Geist here, reminding you to check out the Sunday sit down podcast. On this week's episode, I get together with Larry David to talk about the bittersweet end of his iconic series, curb your enthusiasm and why on earth he decided to cast me on his show in this final season. You can get our conversation now for free wherever you download your podcasts.

For true crime fans, nothing is more chilling than watching Dateline.

Have you ever seen such a thing before?

For podcast fans, nothing is more chilling than listening what goes through your mind.

When you make a discovery like that.

And when you subscribe to DAtelINE Premium, it gets even better.

Excuse me, I sound a little skeptical.

Every episode is ad free.

Ooh, wow.

So this could be your ace in the hole.

And not just ad free. You also get early access to new intriguing mysteries and exclusive bonus content.

So what were you afraid of?

Dateline premium. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or datelinepremium.com.

You ready for what's coming? How many times? I may not know the exact number, but I'm guessing that you and producers reached out to Colin any number of times to try to get him to sit down.

A lot of times. A lot of times. Colin is an interesting character. He was a big star in the cycle racing world. He had big companies sponsoring him right, left, and center. He had a happening life. And all of that came crashing down when this happened. Every single bit of it. His career is in the toilet. He's just a very unhappy guy. I don't blame him. I suppose I would be, too. Anybody would be. You have to wonder. Yeah, I mean, missed certain signs, but.

I mean, he wasn't charged with any crime. No one seems to believe that he was actually involved in this. But come on. Like. Like, do not tell me, pal, that you were not aware of the fact that your girlfriend and this woman did not get along, that there was some significant bad blood that your girlfriend clearly had talked about mo any number of times. I mean, if you're the woman and you get to the point where you're calling the other woman, essentially, say, leave my guy alone. The guy knows about it.

Who knows what his motivations were? I got the sense that of somebody trying to hold his world together. Like, if he just pretended that none of this happened or that the people closest to him didn't do this thing, that life would go on as it was before. But, you know, it's too late for that.

Okay, so you've brought extra sound with you. You've brought us a present.

Indeed.

This is a piece of tape that did not make it into the broadcast. Let's. Let's listen to that. This is. This is Colin being interrogated by police early on.

I think in your gut, you know what happened, and I think you're trying to protect Caitlin right now, which is understandable.

I'm just.

But understand, I don't want you to get wrapped up in anything.

I have no knowledge of what she did. What do I think she did?

Mm hmm.

Things are sounding very, very strange, but I don't. I mean, I don't have evidence. What do you mean to say?

Well, you care about Mo, right?

Of course you do.

Yeah. And so something happened to Mo. Something horrible happened to Mo, and I think you know what happened. Is Caitlyn capable of hurting Mo?

I could not imagine her capable of hurting anyone, to be quite honest. My impression of her is confrontation adverse.

Well, I'm asking you what you think. Is she capable of doing something?

I wouldn't be living with a person who I think is capable doing this, of. I would never in a million years have someone in their house with my mother who I think is capable of this. So the answer is no. I don't believe it.

Okay, you don't believe it. She's confrontation adverse, but you give mo a different name in your phone. That is the action of somebody who wants to avoid a confrontation.

Absolutely.

I don't know whether he is just saying, essentially, I know this person. I have loved this person. I can't conceive of her committing murder, even though I know she's a little angry and she flies out the handle sometimes. I don't think of her as a killer, but, I mean, like, this is not a conversation with your friends over a beer. This is one of those little tiny rooms with the cops, and, like, you know, there's been a murder committed. Come on. I mean, sure. In his interview, he describes Caitlin as one of the least volatile women he's ever dated.

Intuitive guy, clearly.

Yeah. I mean, who else were you going out with? Ma Barker?

I mean, others who knew her, mind you, to whom we spoke, you know, would say that she was not a violent person. But on the other hand, we did talk to some people, too, also, who heard her talking at parties in other places about how she would do terrible things to Mo Wilson if the occasion ever arose.

I mean, this is, you know, this is. Fatal attraction is the thing I keep thinking of. And this is your classic love triangle.

You bet. It's jealousy, as written by Shakespeare and. And Caitlin Armstrong.

Now, I didn't get married until I was 60 years old.

You're 60?

No, I'm way older than that now. But I didn't really get married. I didn't get married until I was 60.

I had you for about 35, Joe.

Oh, this is good. I like this, Keith. Yeah, spoiler alert, it's not gonna last. But, yeah, I was single until I was 60, and Caitlin Armstrong is recognizable to me. I dated women who go through your phone, women who. One followed me around town or said she did. I never knew whether she really did. Another was very interested in making sure that I never had contact with certain people. I'm here to tell you life is too short to be with somebody who doesn't have any boundaries. But this idea that, you know, I mean, taking a life for this romantic relationship, which maybe did or didn't exist, nobody even really knows. I mean, wrecking ending her life, wrecking your life, wrecking her family's life, wrecking your family's life. This is insane.

Yeah, I would have to agree with you.

What about Caitlin's family?

They, you know, they decline their every. And we get it, we understand, and we're not going to push you on it. And we didn't. They're caught in a particularly difficult emotional vice. They'll have to deal with it for the rest of their lives.

I prepared to believe they probably never saw that coming. And again, just because, you know, somebody has a temper or that they can be jealous. That does not translate to you expecting that they're going to commit a murderer.

No, she's, you know, she's the one they knew as the big sister who could be counted on and the fun one who went off and traveled the world and did yoga, et cetera, et cetera. All things that you just do not associated with somebody who is capable of committing a homicide.

All right, after the break, we will come back and we will answer your questions about the episode from social media.

He would lie his way into their dreams.

He was looking for James Bond girls.

How fun would that be to be.

A bond girl, then twist them into a nightmare.

This guy has done this before. He'll do it again.

Until a group of women banded together to put him behind bars and keep.

Him there, you have to participate fiercely, fiercely in what happens next.

I'm Keith Morrison, and this is murder in the Hollywood Hills, an all new podcast from Dateline.

All episodes of Murder, murder and the Hollywood Hills are available now. To listen ad free. Subscribe to dateline premium on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or datelinepremium.com dot.

Okay, let's get to some viewer and listener mail. And the first one is from David in Malibu.

Hey, we know a David in Malibu.

Well, this one says, Josh, did you take up skiing? Because Liz told me you're really going downhill. Oh, wait a minute. That's not. That wasn't viewer mail. That's just a text. Nevermind. Yeah, sorry.

Well, you know, it's an astute remark, I must say. Yeah.

So we got a fair number of pieces of mail about the defense attorney.

Yes, indeed.

Yes. Who says, what if I told you that everything you've said is wrong and that the government's evidence is going to acquit her, right. Yeah. So here's a couple. What if I told you that you look like a smarmy expletive deleted. You, sir, do not deserve to sit in Keith Morrison's vicinity or even breathe the same air. That's from Sherry.

Oh, my goodness.

Yeah, well, I frequently feel that exact same way, but, yeah, well, you know.

I have to say, I mean, I did two interviews with the man, first, when he was being awful of bravado at the beginning of the case, and there was a kind of a strategy at play there, which was that he thought if he could get this fast forwarded to get the case on as quickly as possible, he would have a chance to put the case on, put his defense case on before the prosecution had a chance to get all his ducks in a row. But in the end, when he came back for the second interview, he was chastened. He was very chastened. He comes from a family of attorneys. I can only imagine who chastened him. But he was determined not to say anything at all.

Well, you know, look, I mean, if I were the defendant, I might want that kind of in your face bravado that he was sort of demonstrating and that anybody who accuses my client doesn't know what they're talking about. I mean, you and I both covered plenty of attorneys who come in with guns blazing, and then the verdict ends up changing a little bit.

Yeah, we gotta have something to back it up. You know, you have to have more than just empty bravado, which is, you know, essentially what he was dealing in.

Felicia, a longtime friend of ours here, says, I would love to see your defense attorney's explanation. What if I told you she wasn't trying to flee, but was just trying to stretch her legs? Yeah.

Yeah.

Mark Sardella, who I read all the time on social media, had an interesting point, which I didn't think about earlier, which is, they have her gun as the murder weapon. That's not a circumstantial case.

Well, you know, in the sense that other people had access to the gun, it remained somewhat circumstantial, and they had everything else under the sun. I mean, when he said it was a circumstantial case, I think he was sort of, what is it they do? They kind of play. My case is not as strong as I would like it to be. Game.

Right.

But the case was very solid, and the actual circumstantial evidence was as good as any circumstantial evidence I've ever seen. And I begin to think that that shouldn't be called circumstantial. You know, the fact that they've got the actual sound of the murder, the fact that they've got her car at the murder scene. Yeah.

I mean. I mean, this was a. This was a pretty strong case. One chicklet says, I wonder if her sister is being prosecuted for the passport shenanigans. And the answer is no. She's not.

That is correct. The answer is no, because there's no.

Proof that Caitlin didn't actually steal it.

Right. And that's about the best we can say. Others may have more definitive idea about what happened there, but they're not revealing it. If so.

All right, on to more important things. Nikki Nuvog says that the surfer guy Tl. Ackerson. He's the only person to ever show up for an on camera interview topless on this show, and he must be protected at all costs, I should think.

Yeah, I can see why she might tweet that.

I can't remember anybody else topless on this program.

I can't either. That was kind of a one and only, I think.

You know, I did stories years ago, but this was in the pre crime days. I did stories about this unbelievable rescue of a guy in the water off Hawaii. And I think there might have been some shirtless people in that, but quite possibly. But in the DATelINe crime era, I certainly can't think of anybody.

Josh, I have to confess that speaking of the pre crime era, I myself went topless on a story about Wales, which was really a truly embarrassing time. I don't think it'll ever live it down, frankly.

One of the things that was mentioned, it's not really a question, it's more just information, is about the ride for Mo event that's going to be on May 11 in East Burke, Vermont.

If people are interested in that, I hope they are.

That is talking DatelIne for this week. Keith, thank you.

Oh, Josh. Josh, it's always such a pleasure.

How do you manage to make that sound so phony and yet so genuine.

At the same time?

Thanks, everybody, for listening. Remember, if you have any questions for us about Dateline in general or about any of our episodes, you can reach out to us on social at media dateline NBC. See you Fridays on Dateline.

Friday on an all new Dateline. It was a murder in disguise.

The house was set on fire intentionally.

To cover it up, but the investigation hid secrets of its own.

The police said we have no suspects.

What will it take to uncover the truth?

There were lies upon lies upon lies.

You're just driven to provide your mom justice.

An all new dateline, Friday at nine, eight central, only on NBC.