Happy Scribe Logo

Transcript

Proofread by 0 readers
Proofread
[00:00:00]

There was a time when your important personal information was only in a few places like your wallet, your computer or a safe deposit box. Well, now it's practically everywhere. It's on your mobile devices. It's where you shop, browse bank and do so many other things online. All that online activity can leave you vulnerable to cyber threats. With more threats, you need more protection. That's why Norton 360 with LifeLock provides an all in one membership for your cyber safety, giving you device security, identity theft protection, a VPN for online privacy and more.

[00:00:31]

Plus, if there's a problem, U.S. based agents will work to fix it for you. Now no one can prevent all cybercrime and identity theft, but Norton 360 with LifeLock is your trusted ally in today's connected world, where, let's face it, your info is practically everywhere. Sign up today for a Norton 360 with LifeLock membership and save 25 percent or more off your first year by going to Norton dot com slash matto.

[00:00:55]

That's Norton dotcom slash matto for 25 percent of the Rachel Maddow Show weeknights at nine Eastern on MSNBC.

[00:01:04]

It has been kind of a weird news day. The president this afternoon said out loud that his supporters should try to vote twice in the November election. Voting twice, of course, is a felony. But the president is overtly out loud in public asking his supporters to try it to see if they can get away with it. What do you do with that?

[00:01:28]

I mean, he's not, like, hinting about it. He's not trying to vaguely create the impression that he might want to do that, even though he doesn't say it. I mean, that would be a scandal in its own right. He's just flat out telling people, go try to vote for me twice. Wednesday. Until relatively recently, we were at least kind of a normal country, you know, I mean, ups, ups and downs for sure, things you could take issue with for sure, crises here and there.

[00:01:56]

But like at least we knew how long the number line was like. At least we knew zero to one hundred. Now, though, with presidential behavior like this, the system just kind of kind of breaks. For example, open your heart, soften your heart a little bit and look at the lead on this tonight from our colleagues at NBC News.com. It's perfect. There's absolutely nothing wrong with this lead whatsoever. But the fact that this has to be written, it's like just normal news organizations just aren't built for this level of weird.

[00:02:32]

I mean, it's like if you invited friends over for a barbecue and then you, like, lifted up the cover of the grill and showed them you've got a carburetor and a pair of galoshes there that you're making for dinner like it, just like all of the nouns work until you try to really explain what you're doing and then it just doesn't compute. This is what I mean. Here's this lead from ABC News.com tonight. President Donald Trump suggested today that people in North Carolina should vote twice in the November election, once by mail and once in person, escalating his attempts to cast confusion and doubt on the validity of the results.

[00:03:03]

The president said, quote, So let them send it in and let them go vote. And if their system is as good as they say it is, then obviously they won't be able to vote. If it isn't tabulated, they'll be able to vote. President said this when asked about the mail and voting system in North Carolina. He concluded, quote, So that's the way it is and that's what they should do, he said.

[00:03:26]

And then NBC News has tested a note in the next line. It is illegal to vote more than once in an election. Yes, it is illegal to do what the president just told you to do, and in fact, it is illegal to try to get people to do that.

[00:03:42]

This is a weird day, today is also the day that the Trump administration, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, announced that the United States government will now sanction the International Criminal Court, not the United States, will sanction people sentenced by the International Criminal Court. This is not sanctions on international criminals. This is literally the US government putting sanctions on the people who work at that court. Putting sanctions on people who work at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, the people who prosecute war crimes and stuff, the massacres in Yugoslavia and fucking Nazis and stuff, the US will now sanction the people who prosecute war criminals, the people who administer that courts.

[00:04:27]

Those people will now be sanctioned by the US government as if they're terrorists or cartel leaders or themselves criminals of any kind, all because they work at the International Criminal Court. And under the Trump administration, we're waging war on all international institutions, which we used to support.

[00:04:48]

It's just bizarre, almost non computable behavior by our own government, but apparently that is the order of the day. The president is continuing, as you know, to conduct his reelection campaign, mostly on the grounds that America is burning, that American cities are all on fire and burning down and their terrible health scapes, which is not what life is like in most American cities. But you'd never know that from his ads. But beyond whether or not this scare campaign about US cities is true, it's an awkward message, right?

[00:05:18]

Because even though the president right now is Donald Trump, while he says all of this stuff, this terrible stuff is happening around the country, the president's reelection campaign is now based fundamentally more than anything else. On this premise that this horrible urban hell scape that we are living in now is the future that's in store for the country once Joe Biden is elected president.

[00:05:44]

Well, if this housekeep exists now, why is it here? Well, your president, dude, I mean, it's just it's just like does not compute, right? This is not logical stuff. The president's campaign right now, their fundamental messages, see how terrible things are. Keep me in charge so this won't happen. It's just literal irrationality at the highest levels of American politics and on news days like this, it sort of feels like at all froths at the same time, but it also filters down to local news in weird ways.

[00:06:19]

The Portland Press Herald just posted this online, which I saw this afternoon. It's somebody tweeting at the Portland Press Herald. Can you help me understand the Portland riots? Why haven't you stopped the violence to which the Portland Press Herald responds, Well, we're a newspaper in Maine is the main reason Portland, Oregon, is this place. The president has been scapegoating for protests and unrest. Portland, Maine, home of the Portland Press Herald, is more than three thousand miles away from there.

[00:06:52]

But, you know, I'm sure it's their fault. This is the front page of the Portland Press Herald today, where, again, you can see our national weirdness coming home to the local news. See the headline there. Defiant pastor tied to outbreaks divides local community. This is a fascinating story. Until recently, the little town of Millinocket, Maine, up in the shadow of beautiful Mount Katahdin in Maine, they had been basically untouched by the coronavirus, by covid-19.

[00:07:29]

The Boston Globe reports that in the two neighboring counties there, the whole counties, there had been a total of about one hundred and fifty covid cases over the two counties over the course of six months, which is not a lot. And in Millinocket itself, there had been no cases at all. But that area around little Millinocket, Maine, now has the largest outbreak in that whole state. And it appears to be because of a wedding at a local church and a reception that followed at a local in.

[00:07:58]

This was less than a month ago. It was August 7th. There were reportedly no or very few masks, no social distancing at the event. There were a total of sixty two people in attendance at the wedding and the reception as of now, at least 30 of the sixty two people who attended that wedding and reception have tested positive, 30 of the sixty two, ages four to seventy eight. But of course, it didn't stay confined to the wedding guests.

[00:08:25]

The main Centers for Disease Control has now identified one hundred and forty three cases of coronavirus that are traced back to that one wedding. It's the worst outbreak in Maine. One young person who attended the wedding apparently got infected at the wedding and then went home and infected his or her parent, that parent that apparently infected another child in that same family. That person works at a rehabilitation and living center for seniors in Madison, Maine. And at that senior living center, because of that chain of transmission from the wedding, they've now got multiple staff and patients infected.

[00:09:03]

Another wedding guest was an employee at the county jail in Alfred, Maine, well, as of yesterday, that led initially to we learned initially that that led to 19 staff and thirty five prisoners being infected at York County Jail. As of today, the Press Herald says the numbers at the jail are up to sixty eight cases now among employees and prisoners again traced back to that wedding where the one jail employee attended apparently got infected and then brought it to work.

[00:09:31]

At the venue itself, the venue that hosted the reception, multiple staff members there have now tested positive at the local schools. The East Millinocket school system now has multiple staff and students have become infected. A teacher was apparently working at the wedding reception and then turned up on site to prepare for the school year. And now there are multiple infections at the school, again, among both staff and students. And that means they will not be opening schools in East Millinocket when they thought they would.

[00:09:57]

Among those infected is the local school superintendent.

[00:10:02]

An elderly couple who lives in an isolated wooden cabin on Lake Ceder and Millinocket, they had been isolating at that cabin for months. Throughout the course of the epidemic thus far, because they were older, they had some health issues. They knew they were high risk, even though they also knew they were living in a low risk place that had almost no cases. Well, their community in Millinocket ceased to be a low risk place for them once the virus took hold there after this one super spreader event in town.

[00:10:34]

She was eighty three years old. She died at the local hospital. He's a World War Two veteran. He was hospitalized two days after his wife died. The other place that one wedding seems to have resulted in an outbreak is a town called Sanford, Maine, which is not in that same area. It's a ways away. But the guy who officiated the wedding came from Sanford, Maine. He's the local pastor at a Sanford church and he flew himself in.

[00:11:01]

He's a pilot. He flew himself in to conduct that wedding and then flew home. The Maine CDC announced this weekend on Saturday that they're now investigating a new outbreak at that pastor's church in Sanford, Maine. They've now got multiple cases at that church. Now to that town, also now has an outbreak at their local fire department. Right. You see how these things go, go from zero to 60 really fast. It's a super contagious infectious disease that kills some of the people that it infects.

[00:11:31]

But it's interesting what happened here, the pastor, the guy who officiated the wedding, he goes and performs this wedding in Millinocket, they apparently don't take precautions, or at least not enough. At least one person is now dead. A World War Two vet is hospitalized. There is a jail in Maine that has a big outbreak because of this. There's an old folks home that now has a new outbreak in Maine. Because of this, there's a school in Maine that has a new outbreak.

[00:11:54]

Because of this, the pastor's own church now has an outbreak because of this all derive from this one Kongregate event where people got together and didn't wear masks, they didn't take precautions. And it turns into a super spread event that creates the biggest outbreak in Maine.

[00:12:10]

And the pastor who officiated the service and all of Maine, everybody reading the local news and man, they all learned about this through public reporting and Maine public health authorities tracking it all down and being very transparent about what they are learning. This pastor who officiated the officiate at the service where all of these all of these outbreaks came from, all of these infections came from all of these institutions are now having to be shut down and all of these people are now at risk and one person is dead already.

[00:12:35]

This pastor learns this weekend that now his home church where he came home to after the wedding is itself being investigated as an outbreak because they've got multiple cases there, too. He learns that on Saturday. And what does he do? Following day, he holds multiple in-person services at his church because he doesn't believe that any of this is happening. It matters where people get their information and it matters what people are hearing from people who they accept as leaders.

[00:13:09]

See the headline here from the from the Boston Globe. I want the people of God to enjoy liberty. Pastor. It means super spreader wedding gives defiant endorsement. The officiant of a now infamous wedding in Millinocket gave a defiant sermon during an indoor church service on Sunday, just one day after Maine's Centers for Disease Control announced it was investigating a coronavirus outbreak among those affiliated with his church. Todd Bell, the pastor, portrayed the church he leads as being in the front lines of a culture war, battling against a socialistic platform that mandates mask wearing and distance learning in schools.

[00:13:45]

I'll tell you what the world wants all the churches to do, Bell said during one of two Sunday services. They want us to shut down, go home and let people get used to that just long enough until we can finally stop the advancing of the gospel.

[00:14:01]

Those comments as the Globe echoed political talking points that President Trump and others on the right have used to decry coronavirus restrictions at a rally in New Hampshire on Friday night, for example, the president lamented that Democrats don't believe law abiding citizens can go to church anymore. You can't go to church anymore. He says that on Friday, this pastor finds out he's got an outbreak in his church. On Saturday, he holds services on Sunday. The August 7th wedding at which Bell officiated in East Millinocket has been linked to one hundred and twenty three coronavirus cases in Maine, two more since then.

[00:14:35]

It's about 20 more cases since then. It's the largest outbreak in the state of Maine. That outbreak has also led to the death of an eighty three year old woman who did not attend the event. Bell sermon on Sunday was fiery and unrepentant. At times, he seemed to delight in the provocation, saying he hoped media outlets would watch the service. On Sunday morning, a 15 person choir assembled on stage at his church, Marsalis and singing.

[00:15:02]

He has just taken part in an event that bestowed upon the great state of Maine, the largest outbreak they've had in the state. But, you know, who cares? Screw the Democrats. He told his congregation that masks are pointless. He says there he told them they're like trying to keep a mosquito out of a chain link fence. He told his congregation that he won't take any vaccine for coronavirus if one is developed because of any such vaccine would be abortion.

[00:15:33]

He says that a vaccine is if you take the vaccine, you're supporting abortion. Which is soapbox crazy talk that we're all accustomed to now from. Wherever you find that in your life, except he's kind of the point man in the largest outbreak in his state with one hundred and forty three cases and counting and one dead in a jail, in an old folks home and a school and and and and and all the rest.

[00:15:57]

But you know what, if the people who accept as leaders say this stuff, it matters, it manifests in the world, it turns out it matters what gets said about this stuff from on high. They don't believe law abiding citizens can go to a church together. You can't go to church anymore. You know, many churches are closed in this country because of the Democrats.

[00:16:25]

When the president says stuff like this. Less than 48 hours later, the guy with an active outbreak in his church decides he's going to hold indoor services at his church. Even after he's just led another event that gave it to one hundred and forty plus other people. It matters in the real world, it is a matter of life and death that this is what they are spreading. They closed our churches, people of faith are under attack. You're not allowed to go to church.

[00:16:59]

Democrats won't let you go to church.

[00:17:01]

They don't believe law abiding citizens can go to a church.

[00:17:07]

Secedes citizens, but, you know, if you publicly insist that trying to not spread covid is a Democratic Party plot to ban church and kill God, the results of that in this country is going to be that you're going to have right wing pastors happily spreading covid wherever and whenever they can, because that's what they've heard they should do in order to be a hero.

[00:17:33]

Because any measures to slow the spread of covid, that's a Democratic plot, anti patriotic anti religion, don't fall for it. And you see this manifestation of national politics on the local front pages. I mean, this is the biggest outbreak in Maine. So you're seeing it on the front page of papers in Maine, but you will see this in states all over.

[00:17:56]

And while that is happening, while we see the power of that nonsense at the top manifest in death on the ground. What has emerged this week is that it may no longer even be the policy of the US government to try to stop the spread of covid. We like the fact that there's a lot of cases in low risk populations, because that's exactly how we're going to get herd immunity, population immunity. These people getting the infection is not really a problem.

[00:18:31]

And in fact, as as we said months ago, when you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you're prolonging the problem because you're preventing population immunity. Low risk groups getting the infection is not a problem. In fact, it's a it's a positive. It's a positive.

[00:18:51]

The more people who get infected, the better. That is a man named Scott Atlus, he is not an infectious disease doctor, he's not an epidemiologist. He is a doctor, he's a radiologist. His specialty is in doing MRI of the spine and the brain, which has nothing to do with coronavirus at all. He has no public health experience. Again, no infectious disease experience, no epidemiology experience. But he is apparently the new guy running the US coronavirus strategy at the White House.

[00:19:22]

The president reportedly liked seeing him do these hits on Fox News, these contrarian hits where he proposed this idea that we really ought to just see if we can get everybody infected because that will be better. And with that as his expertise, being a radiologist who gets invited to go on Fox and say this stuff, now he has been brought to the White House and he is apparently sidelined. The other actual qualified experts who were part of the coronavirus task force since Scott Atlus has been sort of taken over and had the president's ear.

[00:19:57]

The White House and the president have started talking about covid and the national strategy, about covid in ways that are new, and that line up with the stated views of this guy who is kind of a crank on the subject. It didn't get a ton of attention when he said it because there was so much else going on. But when the president said this that I'm about to show you at the RNC last week, he was apparently describing a new national strategy for coronavirus.

[00:20:23]

This is not the way that he has described it before. This was the middle of his RNC speech. Again, didn't get a ton of attention, but this is not what he and the White House used to say about how we were tackling this epidemic as a country. We are aggressively sheltering those at highest risk, especially the elderly, while allowing lower risk Americans to safely return to work and to school. And we want to see so many of those great states be open by Democrats.

[00:20:56]

We want them to be open. They have to be open. They have to get back to work. They have to be open, they have to be open, they have to be open, will shelter those in higher risk while allowing lower risk Americans to all return to work in school. Will protect the most vulnerable. You're seeing lots of evidence of that, right, but open everything else back up so that everybody who's lower risk gets infected. This is the herd immunity, the population immunity idea that Dr.

[00:21:25]

Scott Scott Atlus has been snake oil selling on Fox News and Fox News Radio for months before he was brought to the White House to apparently turn this into our new US policy.

[00:21:36]

And if the president really wants to pursue that, some sort of effort to protect those most at risk, but most people encouraged to become infected if we are now pursuing that, which is what this doctor has been publicly advocating, which is apparently what the president is now telling us he wants.

[00:21:54]

It's good for him to start and let us know if this is how he wants us to change tack here, because we should brace ourselves for what this means, that this is what he's going to do.

[00:22:03]

As The Washington Post points out this week, nobody knows if immunity even works the way that these herd immunity, herd immunity theorists believe for covid nobody really knows how much immunity is conveyed by being infected with covid. Nobody also knows how much of the population you'd have to have to actually infect for it to take hold. But if you take these folks at their word and again, that's sort of seen as kind of a crank approach to this subject, but if you take them at their word and you take a kind of conservative estimate about what it would take, if you conservatively estimate that they need, let's say, sixty five percent of the whole population to be infected for this herd immunity idea to work well in the United States with a population of three hundred and twenty eight million people, if you reached a sixty five percent threshold for herd immunity, if you let sixty five percent of the country get infected.

[00:22:54]

If you've had a conservatively speaking, one percent fatality rate. That would mean that you'd have two point one, three million Americans dead. That's what they're aiming for. Those are the most conservative estimates about what something like this would look like, and that would be the good news result, two point one, three million dead. That's if we only have a one percent fatality rate, could be millions more dead if the fatality rate is even slightly higher than that, if it's two percent or three percent, what they're aiming at those over two million dead Americans because a Fox News radiologist says so.

[00:23:30]

And he's apparently outmaneuvered the other experts at the White House and has made this the new US policy. And this is reportedly why the CDC just recommended in the past week all of a sudden that fewer Americans should get tested, this doctor's theory and the fact that he's got the president's ear is reportedly. Why the CDC now says if you've been exposed, you shouldn't necessarily get tested, this new theory the president is spellbound by that says more infected Americans are better.

[00:24:02]

The more people get infected, the better we are. So that means they want to test less people. Even after you've been exposed, if you haven't been tested, after you've been exposed, you don't know you're positive, then you're more likely to spread it to more other people. Under this theory, that's a good thing. The more people infected, the better. This is madness. And it has taken hold at the top of the US government and the president is now propounding this as his big idea for how we should deal with covid from here on out and any Democrats or anybody else in the country that doesn't want this, that wants to stop people from getting infected.

[00:24:38]

They're just trying to shut down your churches. They're just against God. They're just trying to lock you in your home for some sort of nefarious conspiracy. That's where we're at. And coronavirus now, 60 days before this election. Former head of the National Institutes of Health joins us to talk about this next. These past few months, I've become a pro at coloring my hair at home, and that's all thanks to the actual pros at Madison Reed, Madison Reed is game changing color.

[00:25:08]

You can do yourself in under an hour. It's simple to get started. Just go online, take their color quiz to find your perfect shade and they'll deliver it right to your door. With Madison Reed, you'll get all the good stuff. Gorgeous, multidimensional color and nourishing ingredients like argan, oil and keratin without a lot of the bad stuff that usually comes with it. There's no ammonia and no smell whatsoever. And having the freedom to do whatever I want while my color processes is amazing.

[00:25:36]

I can do things like ketchup on my favorite podcasts or finish that puzzle I've been neglecting. You can try it today, starting at just 22 dollars at Madison Dasari Dotcom. Use our code Matto and you'll get ten percent off plus free shipping on your first color kit. Again, that's code matto at Madison Dasch retcon.

[00:25:56]

Hey, everyone, it's Chrissie's. You know, these days I find it helpful to just take a step back from the day to day onslaught of news and take a broader look at the issues I haven't had time to cover on my TV show. All in everything from the legacy of racism in America to how community and creativity can flourish amidst a pandemic, how Democrats could win in deep red America. I do it each week on my podcast. Why is this happening?

[00:26:16]

And I'm joined by uniquely qualified guests like Pulitzer Prize winning reporter Nicole Hannah Jones.

[00:26:21]

Progress does not mean justice or equality or that we are right. After 400 years of black people being in this country, the time for marking incremental progress and patting ourselves on the back for that has been long over. Author Rebecca Solnit.

[00:26:32]

How do we take care of each other in the context of not being able to physically be with each other in ordinary ways? Crooked media. Jon Favreau.

[00:26:40]

It's going to be the highest turnout election in history, which means that it is a persuasion game and many others who help me make sense of what's happening in our society and our world. I really enjoy your conversations. I hope you will, too. So join me for new episodes every Tuesday. Just search for why is this happening wherever you're listening right now and subscribe. In nineteen eighty nine, the Nobel Prize for Physiology or Medicine went to these guys, Dr.

[00:27:03]

Harold Varmus and J. Michael Bishop, a pair of virologists from the University of California who made groundbreaking discoveries about the origins of cancer in the human body. Their research led to all sorts of innovations in cancer detection and cancer prevention. Just four years later, President Bill Clinton appointed one of those two scientists, Dr. Harold Varmus, to lead the National Institutes of Health. He was the first ever Nobel laureate to hold that position. When he was in that post, Dr.

[00:27:31]

Varmus oversaw a massive expansion of the NIH budget. He oversaw the NIH becoming a world leader in research on everything from AIDS to malaria to stem cells. President Obama named Dr. Varmus to the president's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology. Dr. Varmus was appointed director of the National Cancer Institute, where he served until twenty fifteen. He's had just an unbelievably distinguished and accomplished scientific and medical career. And when that's your background, you do not expect to see doctor pharmacist name on top of an op ed like this one, you see the headline there, quote, It has come to this.

[00:28:07]

Ignore the CDC, Dr. Varmus and Rajiv Shah writing in The New York Times this week, quote, We were startled and dismayed last week to learn that the CDC, in a perplexing series of statements, had altered its testing guidelines to reduce the testing of asymptomatic people for the coronavirus. These changes will undermine efforts to end the pandemic, slow the return to normal economic, educational and social activities, and increase the loss of lives. Now, in the face of a dysfunctional CDC, it is up to states, other institutions and individuals to act.

[00:28:43]

This is an up is down, black is white, sort of previously unimaginable thing to hear from somebody who has operated at the highest levels of American public health. Dr. Varmus. Right. He's the former head of the NIH. But that is how bad things are, and I should tell you today, Dr. Varmus is one of eighty one Nobel laureates in science and medicine who issued a joint statement endorsing Joe Biden to be the next president of the United States.

[00:29:07]

Joining us now, I'm honored to say, is Dr. Harold Varmus. Dr. Varmus, I'm really, really pleased that you were able to make time to be with us tonight. Thank you. My pleasure. Thank you very much, Rachel. Let me start by asking you about my characterization of that op ed. It struck me to see your name next to that sentiment, that argument and indeed that headline was jarring to me because of what I know about your history in in health and medicine and science and medicine.

[00:29:39]

Tell me about the decision making process to do that, to go that far. Well, let me say, first of all, I didn't write the headline, the headline was useful because it attracted a lot of readers, but I don't want to be bashing the CDC overall. The CDC is a great institution that's serve the nation well for many years. But they made a mistake in advocating that we test asymptomatic people less frequently. That's the opposite of what we need for reasons you've just laid out very persuasively when you talked about the mysterious Dr.

[00:30:10]

Atlas, we need to test people and to diminish transmission of the virus. And when I tried to do in that piece, along with Dr. Shah, was to explain, first of all, that the testing of asymptomatic people is critical to control of the pandemic, that we have a lot of new tools to do that can do it cheaper. We can do it effectively. We don't need to have the most correct advice from the CDC at the moment, although, frankly, I'm very disturbed by the idea that people who are not as fully familiar with the arguments as many of us are are confused, justifiably confused by having different levels of advice from different components of what appears to be the public health system in the country.

[00:30:53]

That's the part of this function that's very troubling. And I'm trying to explain in that piece why the testing of asymptomatic people is so important. Unlike many other diseases, this one is transmitted by people who have no symptoms and we can prioritize testing. We can't test everybody.

[00:31:10]

Every day would be the extreme, but we can do some sensible things. We can say the following people shouldn't be tested immediately or within a few days of having contact with a person known to be infected. We know some people are greater risk of transmitting the virus. For example, if they go to a sporting event or to a large party or go to work under conditions where they have to be close to their fellow workers.

[00:31:39]

So we're trying to just establish a sensible way to understand the way this virus is transmitted and diminish that by by urging that the states and cities and institutions, including colleges and workplaces where people mingle closely. Dr. Varmus, you described it as a mistake by the CDC, and I hear you when you talk about the sort of confusing nature of the conflicting levels of advice coming out of the CDC. And in your piece, you describe it as dysfunctional. Part of the reason I wanted to talk to you tonight is that I'm worried that this wasn't necessarily a mistake or something that was bungled by the CDC with Dr.

[00:32:25]

Atlus having this role at the White House with the president's change in language about what the US goal is around this, I'm worried that they are deliberately trying to reduce the number of people tested so that we don't find outbreaks, so that there is more spread because they have now become beholden to this idea that the more spread, the better that we can build up enough immunity, that that will somehow save us from having to do anything to really confine this virus because they don't like they don't like what you have to do in order to try to limit its spread.

[00:33:00]

If this is deliberate, if this is if this is a herd immunity idea, how how dangerous is that? Well, it's dangerous and I and I and I resonate with your concerns and I share some of them, but frankly, in the piece that we wrote, rather than speculate about how decisions got made, but we were trying to do, is to look at what was replaced, what was put in place on the CDC website and try to explain to people why this is the wrong thing.

[00:33:27]

And within the context of our twelve hundred words, you can you can explore still uncertain in the mind of of decision that led to this change. And all I can do is, is regret the change and try to change people's minds about what we ought to be doing. Dr. Harold Varmus, Nobel Prize winning scientist, former director of the National Institutes of Health, says it is really an honor to have this much time with you. Thank you so much for making time to be here.

[00:34:00]

Thanks for your service. My pleasure to talk to you, Richard. All right, lots to come tonight as I as I opened up the show tonight. Today has been a weird day in the news. Today has been a weird day in the news uncovered. It's been a weird day in the news on presidential politics. It's also been a weird day in the news when it comes to our greatest international adversary. That story is ahead. Stay with us.

[00:34:27]

Hi, everyone, it's Joy Reid I'm so excited to tell you about my new MSNBC show, the Read Out every weeknight, I'm talking with the biggest newsmakers about the most pressing issues of our time, like Joe Biden, the words of president matter and so is President United States.

[00:34:41]

The first thing I'm going to do is stand up and talk sense and be honest with the American people.

[00:34:46]

Level with them. Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms. We need as many voices as we can have as possible sounding the alarm, encouraging people to wear masks and to take all precautions and to follow the science and the data. Senator Kamala Harris, we send folks into a war wearing camouflage. So what is going on here when you send camouflage uniformed officers into a city and many more?

[00:35:15]

You can listen to the readout as a podcast by searching for the readout. That's r e d o u t one word wherever you're listening right now and subscribing for free. Thanks for listening. One of the most effective political ads of the year so far, if you ask me, is an ad that was launched during the conventions over the past two weeks. It's an absolutely incredible ad, but I think it sort of got squeezed out of the news cycle because of everything else going on around the convention.

[00:35:43]

So I don't know if you have seen this before, but you should see it much. My son was the first person to die in combat under Donald Trump just five days into his presidency. Trump ordered Ryan SEAL Team one into Yev, not from The Situation Room with all the intelligence assembled, but sitting across a dinner table from Steve Bannon.

[00:36:07]

There was no vital interest in play, just Donald Trump playing Big Man, going to war. And when it went horribly wrong, when you lose a 75 million dollar airplane and more importantly, American life is lost and wounded, I don't believe that you can call it a success.

[00:36:23]

Donald Trump demeaned my son's sacrifice to play to the crowd for nearly four years. Trump has assailed our country's core values when Russia put bounties on our troops heads. Trump defended Putin instead of our military. I think it's a hoax. Handicapped the postal service to undermine our right to vote. This election will be the most rigged election in history.

[00:36:47]

He's misled us throughout the pandemic. No, I don't take responsibility at all. Two hundred thousand Americans will have died before we vote. They and Ryan have one thing in common. It didn't have to be. But for Donald Trump, if you hear one thing, let it be this. Don't trust Donald Trump with your kids life or your own. Remarkable ad that was produced during the conventions by the veterans group Vote Vets. I'll tell you, we've reached out to that Gold Star father, Bill Owens, for comment on that ad.

[00:37:25]

We, of course, would love to speak to him at some point about this. But as of now, it doesn't seem like he's doing any public statements other than that remarkable ad that we just showed you. Certainly that should be enough.

[00:37:38]

Meanwhile, the organization that produced that with Bill Owens, boat vets, they really have been punching above their weight in this election cycle, both in terms of this kind of content they have been able to bring to the fore, but also some very well-timed stuff, including this I'm going to show you today, which they put out time to coincide with the president doing an event in front of a battleship today. Donald Trump is panicking, finding any excuse to show up in military communities.

[00:38:08]

He knows if elections were held today, he'd lose the military vote in a landslide. 60 percent of active duty officers disapprove of his presidency because Donald Trump disrespects those who serve. He's not a war hero, war hero. I like people that weren't captured, OK? Our troops are in more danger today because of Donald Trump's betrayals. He abandoned our Kurdish allies in Syria, playing into Russia's hand. He wouldn't stand up for our troops. When Putin put bounties on their heads in Afghanistan, his weakness emboldens the enemy.

[00:38:43]

Now Russia is directly engaging U.S. troops, slamming into our patrols in Syria, intercepting our bombers and flying their bombers dangerously close to American airspace. Trump's refusal to defend America's national security is dangerous. His refusal to stand up for our troops is humiliating. His threat to deploy active duty troops against American citizens is unconstitutional. So when it comes to the military vote for the next commander in chief, Trump's not leading. He's losing. New ad today from again Vote Vets, which has been doing just these very effective, very hard hitting, very pungent anti Trump ads over the course of this whole cycle and that point that they are making from a veterans perspective about how America Trump's refusal to defend America's national security is dangerous.

[00:39:44]

His refusal to stand up for our troops is humiliating that the United States is being hurt by Trump being so subservient and weak when it comes to Russia. That is a very live issue, not only in politics right now, but in the news today. ABC News was first to report on the Trump administration blocking the release of a of a Homeland Security intelligence bulletin that was meant to warn law enforcement agencies around the country about Russia interfering to help Trump win the November election by promoting false propaganda that's circulating first in Russian propaganda outlets about Joe Biden supposedly being in poor mental health.

[00:40:22]

That bulletin about Russia promoting that line against Biden to interfere in our elections. That bulletin was done in July. It was set to be released to federal, state and local law enforcement agencies. But the Trump administration pulled it at the very last minute and wouldn't let it get out. Two months later. That intelligence warning still has not gone out. The Trump campaign, of course. Meanwhile, has been pushing that exact line against Joe Biden, even as Russian propaganda outlets have been pushing it to, even as that's part of the Russian interference effort.

[00:40:52]

They are dovetailing their own efforts with that. The only thing the Trump administration has done is stop the US public from being warned that that is part of a Russian government operation. And you know, this Trump sort of subservience to Russia in instances like this, obviously it serves his interests, but it has an impact on the country as a whole.

[00:41:19]

And it has a very, very important and pointed relevance point of relevance to what's happening right now with Russia in the world and with Russia in their behavior towards Russia as of today, is now being blamed for yet another nerve agent, attempted assassination of Russian opposition figure Alexei Navalny. We're also in the past week seeing direct physical confrontations between Russian and US troops. The president has so far been silent on both of these matters. This isn't just a political issue for the election.

[00:41:55]

This is live for the news right now. Former US Russia Ambassador Michael McFaul is going to join us live next to talk about it.

[00:42:02]

Stay with us. Today, German Chancellor Angela Merkel confirmed that toxicology results from a German army lab contained, in her words, unequivocal proof that Alexei Navalny, the Russian opposition leader, was poisoned with a Russian military grade nerve agent. Novacek, the same type of nerve or nerve agent used in a twenty eighteen attack on former Russian spy Sergei Skripal in the U.K. Alexei Navalny remains in a medically induced coma and on a ventilator in a hospital in Berlin, he said, by doctors there to be in critical but stable condition.

[00:42:40]

But this announcement today from the German government, this definitive conclusion that Russia effectively was behind the attack, that once again they used a Russian military poison that would tell the world for sure that it was them. That conclusion today drew forceful responses from the leaders of the UK and the European Union and NATO and other European countries here in the US. Not so much. The president still hasn't said a word about this at all. Joining us now is former US ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul.

[00:43:12]

Professor McFaul. Thanks very much for joining us.

[00:43:14]

It's nice to see you. Good to see you. Thanks for having me, Rachel. So you've called on President Trump to join other world leaders in condemning the poisoning of Navalny.

[00:43:24]

He obviously has not done so. He's not talked about it at all. How how would it matter if if he did what how what difference would it make if he did? Well, it goes to the point that you were just making earlier, that he is weak before Putin, he doesn't push back on anything. And so Putin thinks he can do anything, whether it's running into our soldiers in Syria or perhaps putting bounties on our soldiers heads in Afghanistan.

[00:43:50]

And now perhaps we don't know the facts. I want to underscore, we don't know all the details about what happened to Mr. Navalny, but he doesn't do anything.

[00:43:59]

And it means that we're not leading the free world, Rachel. So look at all those statements you just put. We are not even trying to catch up to them. We are behind. And that lack of unity in the democratic world makes America weaker across the board, not just with respect to Russia, but with respect to all of our adversaries around the world. We have frequently seen the presidents exhibit this profound weakness and subservience and just weakness around the issue of Russia, even when other people in his own government won't go along with it in this case.

[00:44:34]

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo seems to be going along with it. He did a press conference today on the day that Merkel said that Germans confirmed that it was a Novacek poisoning. It did a press conference. They didn't say a word about it. That said, we did get a National Security Council short series of tweets condemning it and saying that the US will work with allies to hold Russia accountable. I mean, I was happy to see that statement from the National Security Council, but that's kind of strange, right, to not have the president of the secretary of state talking about it at all and instead to have this kind of subtle, unsigned statement from an amorphous body.

[00:45:11]

Correct, because those words of that person and you probably can't even name that person, right, I can't means nothing compared to the words of the president of the United States. And I want to underscore, this is not just a one off. President Trump has said nothing about the Democratic protests in Belarus. He said nothing about the foreign influence that Russia is doing right now in our democratic elections. In other words, he's not defending the sovereignty of the United States of America.

[00:45:39]

And I think this is hard for people to understand. Like if the Chinese ships came into the San Francisco Bay, we would expect our government to tell us about that threat because it would be physical. We could see it, you could do video of it. But because it's a digital threat, we don't see it. But it's the same thing. Putin is violating our sovereignty. We should be pushing back on that. This reporting today, which is initially from ABC News and a number of other news organizations, including NBC, have now confirmed that the Homeland Security Department had an intelligence briefing ready to go, warning not just generally that Russia is interfering in the election, but specifically if you see story lines out there about Joe Biden having mental health issues, those are things that are being launched by the Russian government in Russian propaganda outlets, laundered through their social media avatars.

[00:46:31]

And they are trying to use that and insert that storyline into the US election in order to hurt Biden's campaign. They had that intelligence briefing ready to go. The Trump administration has stopped it from going out. Does it matter to be to the American people to not be sort of inoculated in that way against that form of interference? Of course it does. It's outrageous that they are done denying the American voters this information. And Rachel, I want to remind you, you and I talked about this in the fall of 2016 when we are at least I on your show, was critical of the Obama administration for not putting out more information about the threats at that time, because the voters need to know what the Russians are doing.

[00:47:16]

If they're trying to influence our vote, at least letting them know that they're doing it might help them to make more balanced decisions about what they do in November. I just think it's absolutely outrageous. It's not enough to debrief the intelligence committees. They need to be briefing the American people about these activities. Former US ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul, professor, it's always good to have you here. Thank you so much for your time. But to be here, thanks for having me.

[00:47:44]

All right, more to come tonight. Do stay with us. That is going to do it for us tonight, I will tell you that since we have been on the air tonight, we got the very sad news that Hall of Fame pitcher Tom Seaver has died. He was seventy five years old. He died with covid-19. He was a 12 time all star, 20 years in the major leagues. The US Marine Corps veteran served in the he pitched in the major leagues nineteen sixty seven and nineteen eighty six.

[00:48:16]

He was elected to the Hall of Fame in nineteen ninety two. He was named on ninety nine percent of the ballots that were cast that year. Tom Seaver has passed away at the age of seventy five. Sad news. All right. That is going to do it for us tonight.

[00:48:26]

The Rachel Maddow Show weeknights at nine Eastern on MSNBC.